Text Version
At the Crossroads for Mission in Vietnam by Clinton Rabb

Vietnamese United Methodists celebrated their twentieth anniversary in June 2000 at the Wesley United Methodist Church in San Diego, CA. When I arrived for the celebration, scores of Vietnamese children, youth, and adults were visiting and having fellowship on the church grounds, enjoying the beautiful California morning. We soon gathered for worship, with speeches, sermons, music, and prayers of thanksgiving for new life in Jesus Christ and for The United Methodist Church. Following that, we adjourned to the fellowship hall for a feast of Vietnamese food. As we ate and shared in fellowship, my thoughts went back to a previous time of Christian feasting and fellowship.

Photo of women with heads bowed.

Worshipers at the Evangelical Church of Vietnam in Ho Chi Minh City.
Photo by Richard Lord.


No Longer Strangers

Almost 25 years ago, I came to know a Vietnamese refugee family whose members became a large part of my life. I was associate pastor at Colonial Hills United Methodist Church in San Antonio, Texas. I was assigned the task of setting up a team to resettle a Vietnamese refugee family. We found an apartment and furnished it. We helped the family find English language classes and conducted a job search for the father and older children.

Over time, aunts, uncles, sisters, brothers, and cousins joined the original family. In a relatively short time, the family was on its own and self-sustaining. Not long after that, the Vietnamese family invited me and the other members of the team to a meal in their home. It was a time of warmth and gratitude as they returned the hospitality that had been offered to them by the church.

When Saigon fell in 1975, Vietnamese refugees poured into the United States. The United Methodist Church, through UMCOR and the General Board of Global Ministries, called on congregations to assist in the resettlement of Vietnamese refugees. As always, the church responded by offering sanctuary and hospitality. Colonial Hills UMC, like so many other United Methodist churches at the time, opened its doors.

Now, 25 years later in San Diego, we were celebrating God's new creation of a Vietnamese United Methodist community. The Vietnamese are no longer strangers; they are now a vital and indispensable part of The United Methodist Church. The Vietnamese National Caucus of The United Methodist Church is engaged in evangelizaton and leadership-development ministries in Vietnamese communities in the United States and back in Vietnam.

In recent years, Vietnamese United Methodist doctors and health-care professionals associated with the Vietnamese United Methodist Youth Fellowship have traveled to Vietnam to set up clinics and conduct medical missions.

Religion in Vietnam

The taxi we rode in slipped through the streets of Ho Chi Minh City (Saigon), among the thousands of small motorcycles that coursed the streets like the corpuscles in a vein. We were a team from the General Board of Global Ministries traveling to Vietnam on request of the Vietnamese National Caucus of The United Methodist Church. A group of Vietnamese Christians had conveyed a desire to know more about The United Methodist Church and its ministries. We came to listen, worship, and share fellowship.
A small white statue of a woman in a flowing gown stood on the dashboard of the small cab. On first glance, it appeared to be the Virgin Mary. As I looked closer, I saw that it was the image of a serene Asian woman. I saw that image again later on the way to our hotel. This time, she was a statue over 20 feet tall, standing in a sheltered space facing the street.


A Vietnamese family on a motorbike, Ho Chi Minh City.
Photo by Richard Lord.

Chinese Influences

The figure is Kuan Yinh, a Bodhisattva in the tradition of Mahayana Buddhism. Many Vietnamese Buddhists believe that she offers a kind and compassionate heart to those in trouble, especially as the protector of barren women. A Bodhisattva in the tradition of Mahayana Buddhism is an enlightened being who has delayed entrance into Nirvana out of compassion for the suffering people. Mahayana Buddhism was introduced to Vietnam from China in the first century.

Buddhism focuses on the human problem of suffering and pain. Buddha said: "Suffering I teach — and the way out of suffering." The Eightfold Path encompasses wisdom, morality, and meditation. In Mahayana Buddhism, the principal form of Buddhism practiced in Vietnam, compassion is elevated to the level of wisdom, which can be seen in the reverence for Kuan Yinh. Buddhism has the largest number of followers in Vietnam. According to the 2000 Annual Report on International Religious Freedom released by the US State Department, about 40 million Vietnamese, or half of the population, are nominally Buddhist.

While Buddhism is the primary religion followed in Vietnam, Vietnamese religion is an amalgam of other traditions. Thatch Nhat Hanh, a Buddhist monk and leader of the Vietnamese peace movement of 1970, wrote concerning the religious tradition of Vietnam: "We find elements of Buddhism, Taoism, and Confucianism intimately mixed together, along with still other native beliefs that existed even before the three great religions were introduced...."

Buddhism became overlaid on these native or animistic beliefs. Animism is the belief that animate spirits inhabit all inanimate objects. This, the ancient religion of Vietnam, still provides the bedrock for all succeeding religious movements in Vietnam. A key component of animism is the veneration of the dead. Elaborate rituals developed as a way of appeasing and satisfying the ancestors, who were believed to control the fate of the living. Rice harvests depended on the goodwill of the ancestors. Famine and flood were a result of unhappiness and dissensions in the heavens.

Taoism came from China during the first centuries when China began its dominance over Vietnam. By this time, Taoism no longer had much to do with the teachings of its founder, Lao Tzue. The practice of Taoism seeks to keep the forces of Yin and Yang in balance. However, in place of the clear, uncompromising philosophy of its earlier exponents, it was intermingled with spirit belief and magic cults in Vietnam.

With the Chinese also came the Confucian ordering of society. Confucian teachings regard humankind as basically good and knowledge and learning as the paths to happiness and success. The Confucian intellectuals rejected animistic practices of the peasants as superstitious, which resulted in the division of Vietnam into two social classes: peasants and mandarins. From the tenth century to the beginning of the nineteenth century, Vietnam was governed by Chinese mandarins. To be appointed as mandarins, Vietnamese leaders were required to undergo examinations in which their knowledge of Chinese and of Confucian principles was tested. Those who passed were responsible for the proper ordering of the state. Those who tried but failed became the medical professionals and shopkeepers.


A mother and daughter prepare beans for a meal, Binh Quay, Vietnam.
Photo by Richard Lord.

Roman Catholicism

On a beautiful Sunday morning as we traveled through Ho Chi Minh City to meet a group of Christians, we passed a large Roman Catholic Church. Gathered on the grounds were more than 1000 people. The Roman Catholic Church was introduced to Vietnam in the sixteenth century by French monks. Under French rule in the 1850s, membership in the Catholic Church became a prerequisite for employment, particularly in government. Over time, the Roman Catholic Church was composed of the Vietnamese elite. Converting to Catholicism became a way of demonstrating loyalty to the government. This held true even up until the reign of Ngo Dinh Diem in the early 1960s. According to the 2000 Annual Report on International Religious Freedom, Vietnam has about 6 million Roman Catholics, representing 8 percent of the population. On February 21, Pope John Paul installed François Xavier Nguyen Van Thuan, 72, as one of 44 new cardinals. He had been imprisoned by Communists after the fall of Saigon when he refused to give up his post as Bishop of Vietnam.

Other Religions

A much more recent development in the religious life of Vietnam is the establishment of the Caodai Church. Caodai began in the early 1920s and grew rapidly through 1941. The name literally means "high tower or palace." Caodai combines the compassion of Buddhism with the ethics of Christianity, the spiritism of Animism and Taoism, and the organizational particularity of Confucianism and the Roman Catholic Church.

Hoa Hoa is a reformed Buddhist sect that was established in the 1930s. By the end of World War II it had over a million adherents. It stresses that virtue is the path to salvation.

Protestant Christianity

We traveled by van down side streets until we came to a busy motorcycle repair shop. There were motorcycles in various states of repair, with mechanics bent over them. No one looked up as we climbed a set of narrow stairs along the wall to the second floor. I heard the familiar music of "What a Friend We Have in Jesus" as I reached the landing. I saw over 200 people standing and singing.

Following the close of the service, the pastor told me that the French colonial government had resisted the establishment of Protestant Christianity in Vietnam. However, in 1911, the Christian and Missionary Alliance (CMA) sent missionaries.

The CMA was originally a missionary-sending organization founded by a Presbyterian minister. It later became a Protestant denomination. Today, the Evangelical Church of Vietnam (ECV) carries on the CMA tradition. The ECV has been in negotiation with the Vietnamese government for many years over its official status.

On February 9, 2001,Vietnam officially recognized the southern branch of the Evangelical Church of Vietnam. The ECV is a network of Tin Lanh (Good News) churches. According to the 2000 Annual Report on International Religious Freedom, there are over 300 Tin Lanh churches, primarily south of the Ho Chi Minh City, with 15 churches in the Hanoi area.

Some leaders of house churches, many of which are Pentecostal, a small minority of the Protestants in Vietnam, have been critical of the ECV's quest for recognition by the government for fear that it will come under the control of the government. In turn, the Vietnamese government has been suspicious of the house-church movement because the congregants meet in private homes in secret.

Crossroads for Mission

When the GBGM team met in January with Vietnamese Christians, it was the culmination of conversations among representatives of The United Methodist Church, the GBGM, the Vietnamese National Caucus of The UMC, and Vietnamese Christians that had been ongoing since 1998. The initial visit to Vietnam in 1998 included Bishop Roy Sano, then episcopal leader of the California Pacific Annual Conference. Vietnamese Christians expressed interest in The United Methodist Church and wanted to know more about it. One had spent much of his adult life under house arrest because he had refused to give up his ministry in 1975. He had read the works of John Wesley and wanted to know more. The Vietnamese women present were keenly aware that women are an integral part of United Methodist lay and clergy leadership. Others expressed interest in the organizational and connectional nature of the church.

Who Are the People Called Methodists? by Dr. S T Kimbrough offers a concise description of the history, beliefs, and order of The United Methodist Church. We had it translated into Vietnamese for the purposes of our visit. We gathered with 16 Vietnamese men and women for two days. We heard about how they struggle to practice their faith. We ate together, sang together, learned from one another, and worshiped together.

Vietnam is undergoing change as a new generation of leaders is arising. The government of Vietnam is increasingly recognizing its own constitutional mandates for the freedom of religion. Now, 25 years after the end of what the Vietnamese call "the American War," The United Methodist Church is being urged by its own Vietnamese American constituents and by Vietnamese Christians to bear witness to Jesus Christ in Vietnam.

Dividing line indicates end of article - 775 Bytes

The Rev. Clinton Rabb is an executive for Special Initiatives in Evangelization and Church Growth at the General Board of Global Ministries.

Next Article - 458 Bytes Indochina

Text and photographs copyright 2001 by New World Outlook: The Mission Magazine of The United Methodist Church. Used by Permission. For reprint permission, contact New World Outlook by E-mail at nwo@gbgm-umc.org.

Link to NWO May/June contents page - 851 Bytes  Link to NWO subscription page - 790 Bytes  Link to GBGM Homepage - 733 Bytes